Globalization Sovereignty Essay

is globalization undermining state sovereignty?

1559 Words7 Pages

Although it already existed long before through primitive trade and migration, globalization has become a major factor in the world organization since the twentieth century. With the creation of transnational companies, intergovernmental and non-governmental organizations, political and economic associations appeared new powerful actors that cannot be left apart in states’ decisions and whose influence may, according to some, threaten the authority of nation-states. Indeed it can be thought that globalization is causing the end of borders between countries and what is more that it is creating a sort of universal society in which states’ sovereignty is not the main authority anymore. However this essay will try to demonstrate that…show more content…

According to him internationalization characterize the ‘growing interdependence between states’ by suggesting that there is still a ‘discrete national unit’ and concrete borders, while globalization is defining a process of abolition of the distinction between the domestic and the external. Finally regionalization concerns ‘transnational or transregional networks’ and the interconnectedness between states sharing borders or located in the same geographic area (2011, pp. 19-20). Therefore globalization is defined as a phenomenon of global exchanges, such as trading, which leads to bound economies, but also information and news that allow a good communication between states. Migration and tourism are extremely important too. McGrew points out that there are ‘tens of millions’ legal and illegal immigrants and over six hundred million tourists moving across the globe per year (2011, p. 16). So globalization enables people to share common news and cultures by means of a global market that aims to offer similar goods around the world. The Oxford English Dictionary offers the same definition writing that globalization is ‘the process by which business or other organizations start operating on a global scale’ (2011, p. 605). A next term to define properly is sovereignty. McGrew writes that it is the ‘supreme, unqualified and exclusive political and legal authority’ of states and governments within their territory (2011, p. 23). The definition proposed by the Oxford

Show More

Globalization And State Sovereignty Essay

INTRODUCTION
There is an undeniable fact that there has been a rise in globalization. It has become a hot topic amongst the field of international politics. With the rise of globalization, the sovereignty of the state is now being undermined. It has become an undisputed fact that the world has evolved to a new level of globalization, the transferring goods, information, ideas and services around the globe has changed at an unimaginable rate. With all that is going on, one would question how globalization has changed the system that is typically a collection of sovereign states. Do states still have the main source of power? What gives a state the right to rule a geographically defined region? It is believed by many that due to the introduction of international systems and increasing rate of globalization, the sovereignty of the state has been slowly eroded over time. My paper has two parts: First, it aims to take a close look at how globalization has changed the way the economy worked, specifically how it opened doors for multinational corporations to rise in power. Second, to answer the question, is it possible for it to exist today? And even so, should it?
SOVEREIGNTY
Before we delve deeper into this topic, it is imperative to properly provide a definition of sovereignty and lay down some foundation on this topic. There are four different definitions of sovereignty – international legal sovereignty, Westphalia sovereignty, domestic sovereignty and interdependence sovereignty. International legal sovereignty deals with “the practices associated with mutual recognition, usually between territorial entities that have formal juridical independence” (Krasner 4). The main definition of sovereignty that this paper will use is the Westphalian definition of it: which is “political organization based on the exclusion of external actors from authority structures within a given territory” (Krasner 5). Domestic sovereignty is based on the effectiveness of the legitimate authority within restrictions of their policies and the extent to which that authority can be effectively exercised. Lastly, Interdependence sovereignty deals with the capability of public authorities to regulate the flow of information, goods, people, pollutants, or capital across borders from their state (Krasner 5). While these are four different definitions of sovereignty, De Benoist says that traditional sovereignty has either one of two definitions: The first of the two definitions is “the capacity of the public power to impose its authority”. The second of the definitions is “the holder of the legitimate power, who is recognized to have authority” (99). While each definition seems to differ from the other, they all have power and authority at the centre of their definitions (De Benoist 100).
This main goal of this paper is to take a critical look on the relationship between globalization and state sovereignty. With the discussion of globalization, it is important that we see...

Loading: Checking Spelling

0%

Read more

The Importance of Sovereignty Today Essay

2362 words - 9 pages Is the concept of sovereignty beneficial in our lives today despite the onset of globalization? While many people may argue that the benefits of globalization outweigh those of sovereignty, few would recognize the fact that there is still a need for sovereign states in our societies today in order to eliminate, for instance, the demise of the middle class, and the social disintegration between lower wage earners and higher salary earners that...

What is meant by globalization? To what extent has the authority of nation-states been eroded by globalization?

2130 words - 9 pages With the turn of the 21st century, most nation states around the world accelerated their rate of opening their economies to global trade. With such a proactive approach, these domestic economies hope to not only develop their GDP but also create new market opportunities. By integrating their national economy into the global market they also look towards expanding trade, and political alliances (.However, to join the international...

Is there evidence to suggest that sovereignty as a corner stone of modern politics crumbling?

2377 words - 10 pages Sovereign states are the basic and indispensable building blocks of the international system. However in modern politics, there are many times where sovereignty is seen to be crumbling. This essay, aims to examine evidence to see if sovereignty as the cornerstone of modern politics, is actually crumbling. It will examine and analyze vital organisations, phenomenon’s, and situations such as globalization, the United Nations, the European Union and...

Sovereignty is of declining significance in international relations

1921 words - 8 pages Carl Schmitt once stated, “The protego ergo oblige” (n.d); meaning I protect therefore I oblige. This is the basis of a key aspect of International Relations: Sovereignty. Theoretically, it can be defined as the supreme power or authority. Sovereignty as a concept plays a critical role in maintaining international order however has been interpreted in several different ways; its context in theory and in reality. In order to appreciate...

Culture Drives Globalization

1772 words - 7 pages The term ‘globalization’ did not come about till the twentieth century however the processes of globalization had been around since the era of imperial domination. “The controversy surrounding the on-going debates about globalization is whether unfettered market forces will further diverge or converge income the world over. On the one hand, proponents of globalization say it has promoted information exchange, led to a greater understanding of...

Does Globalization increase the prospects for peace in world politics?

765 words - 3 pages [Type text] Does Globalization increase the prospects for peace in world politics?By globalization we simply mean the process of increasing interconnectedness between societies such that events in one part of the world more and more have effects on peoples and societies far away (Baylis &Smith, 2005:8). It involves the...

Globalization: A Free Trade Phenomenon

1063 words - 4 pages Globalization is “the integration of states through increasing contact, communication and trade to create a holistic, single global system in which the process of change increasingly binds people together in a common fate” (Carey 2002). Some economists recognize globalization as being in the best interest of all states. While others believe that increasingly liberated trade and global economic interaction is necessary in many ways. While...

State sovereignty

2098 words - 8 pages In this essay, I would like to discuss the importance of state sovereignty in a globalised world. I will be going in depth with the political, economic and cultural/social dimensions of globalisation and there will be two main channels through which I will be explaining the importance, the first being how interconnected different countries are due to the various dimensions of globalisation and second, how this interconnectedness between...

Globalization: The Big Friendly Giant

1713 words - 7 pages It does not matter who you are, or what you do for living; it does not matter where you live, or where you come from; either way, you have come into contact with globalization. We are all active members of this web, and we are the fuel it needs to work to perfection. This web needs employers and employees, it needs people in need and people willing to help, and it needs members of different cultures and societies. It needs you. Whether it was by...

Define and compare between the following interpretations of globalization (about 600 words). 1. Optimistic. 2. Pessimistic. 3. Traditionalist. 4. Transformationlist.

720 words - 3 pages Introduction:-There are no specific definition or explain about the globalization because almost every thing in our life can be consider as globalization, in general we can said, it is a small village that integrate language, religion, education and create new economic and culture zones within and across nations, and it doesn't only concern the material and technological sphere and social structures also it reaches deep into value systems,...

Globalization In Turkey

2169 words - 9 pages Globalization is the concept through which regional markets join in using a universal network to improve governmental ideas via communication, transport and trade. The concept is closely related to that of economic globalization which integrates national economies into the international economy. Such integration is achieved by trade, foreign direct investment, capital flows, and migration. Bhagwati (2004) observes that at a higher level it can...

0 comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *